"When the Moon Was Ours" by Anna-Marie McLemore
Originally Published 2016
Pages: 318
Awards: James Tiptree, Jr. Award 2016 and Stonewall Book Award Honor 2017
Summary: When the Moon Was Ours tells the story of a young woman that has magical roses growing out of her arms and a young man who is transgender that navigates life and relationships under the threat of dangerous girls rumoured to be witches. The story explores navigating trauma, identity and self acceptance all under the genre umbrella of fantasy/ sci-fi.
I chose this book because it falls under one of my own personal favorite genres while still embodying the plights of the young adults. This book explores LGBTQ+ themes in a way that is captivating and full of literary devices and techniques
Teaching and Content Considerations:
This book covers identity in tremendous detail and would be a great primary text if there were room for a few week identity study in the classroom. The book explores being transgender or struggling with identity, love, friendships in a variety of scenarios. This book would be great to study characterization as well as come to grips with aspects of students' own identities. The themes of transformation, self acceptance and love are also very powerful in this book. For students that are going through similar transitions in their lives they would do well to see and read about these themes for themselves.
This book was intended for anybody between the ages of 12-18 but with the themes of violence, trauma, etc. it might be more appropriate for a more mature audience. 9th and 10th grade would be the target if I were to teach this book.
This book would be more of a whole group instruction book. While students could and should read individually there are several themes that would be best done as a whole group so there is a more guided presentation of the events of the book as well as how to best go about handling those.
There are many excerpts that would be important to study but one of the passages that sticks out to me most is on page 9 of the book. The Quote that I would have students closely read is " The understanding settled on her that it was Sam, not that wooden-hilted brush, that held the magic of turning a vine-laced field into a thousand pumpkins." This passage shows how powerful and important the person behind the action is and when thinking about identity it is important to understand that people have the power to transform and make things happen in their lives.
Another excerpt that would be important for students to do a close reading of is pages 290-292. Not only do these pages touch on identity as well but they are littered with figurative language and literary devices. With quotes like "Their stare was heavy as a coating of snow" or "Maybe fear had twisted it, leaving it threadbare" These few passages toward the end of the book would be good for students to look at to see how figurative language changes the feel, tone of a story and what effect it has on a reader in general.
This book I think would be great in an identity study. That being said I could also see lots of excerpts and quotes being used in this book to teach general figurative language study. The way the author presents the characters in such a surreal magical way would be helpful for students to see in mimicking this type of genre writing.